In a nationwide press conference in 2003, George W. Bush's attorney general, the born-again John Ashcroft, trumpeted the arrest of Dr. Sami Al-Arian, who he described as "the most dangerous man in the world."
In announcing the 120-page indictment, Ashcroft charged that Al-Arian and his three co-defendants played "a substantial role in international terrorism"They finance ... and assist acts of terror. Our message to them is clear: We make no distinction between those who carry out terrorist attacks, and those who knowingly finance, manage, or supervise terrorist organizations." He charged that Al-Arian had been actively funding terrorist attacks in
All that was nine years ago. Nine years. And, in one form or another, Dr. Al-Arian has pretty much been incarcerated ever since.
Incarcerated not in some tinpot dictatorship, but in the United States of America. The same America that prides itself on the fairness and integrity of its criminal justice system and the rule of law.
As Glenn Greenwald wrote in Salon: "Each time it appears that [Al-Arian's] plight will finally be over, the U.S. Government concocts a new process to ensure that he remains a prisoner."
This is how it happened:
Rewind to the mid-1990s. That's when the FBI began its decade-long surveillance of Dr. Al-Arian. A Palestinian born in
Things began to turn sour for Al-Arian after his university tried to fire him following his guest appearance on Bill O'Reilly's show, The Factor, on Fox News. It was clear that USF was looking for a pretext to make the Al-Arian story go away. The DOJ finally indicted Al-Arian on Feb, 20, 2003, and accused him of backing organizations fronting for Palestinian Islamic Jihad - a 1997 State Department-designated "Foreign Terrorist Organization (FTO)."
It charged Al-Arian with multiple counts of conspiracies to provide material support for this organization. The mountain of wiretaps, emails, speeches, lectures, and much more the FBI collected from Dr. Al-Arian, would constitute the government's case against him.
A week after Al-Arian's indictment, University of South Florida president Judy Genshaft fired him with the backing of then Governor Jeb Bush, and pressure from a vocal segment of the "Israel right or wrong" US foreign policy establishment.
And despite the Constitutional guarantee of a speedy trial, the
The period leading up to the trial was marked by shrill and frequently inaccurate public accusations against Al-Arian. Many of the more outrageous came from Fox News and from Steve Emerson, a self-styled "terrorism expert" best known for his off-the-wall predictions of impending terrorist attacks on the homeland. Emerson runs a not-for-profit outfit called The Investigative Project on Terrorism, and also has a for-profit company that does corporate and government consulting.
Among some of his more notorious claims, Emerson told a reporter shortly after the 1995
The blogosphere was also alive with right-left battles over the Al-Arian case. The mainstream print press appeared to be as clueless as usual in its coverage of legal proceedings. As it struggled to understand the legalese of the courtroom, it frequently elected to write about the easier-to-understand personal conflicts of the principals in the case or turn to accessible but unreliable sources, such as Emerson.
And as for cable news, including Fox, most coverage was reduced to minimally-informative sound bites.
But the tone of the press coverage, often quoting government officials, seemed to guarantee that the post-9/11 hysteria would frame the Al-Arian trial as if the government had designed it.