Share on Google Plus Share on Twitter
  4
Share on Facebook Share on LinkedIn Share on PInterest Share on Reddit Share on StumbleUpon Tell A Friend 4 Shares     
Printer Friendly Page Save As Favorite View Favorites View Article Stats
1 comment

General News

Sorry's Not Good Enough in Afghanistan. Here's Why.

By (about the author)     Permalink
Related Topic(s): ; ; ; ; ; ; , Add Tags Add to My Group(s)

Supported 2   Must Read 1   Well Said 1  
View Ratings | Rate It

opednews.com

This article was co-authored by Robert Greenwald and Derrick Crowe

As violence continues following the burning of Korans by ISAF in Afghanistan, insiders in Washington, D.C. and in the media are wasting quite a bit of breath asking the rhetorical question, "Why aren't the apologies working?" Military commanders in Afghanistan apologized profusely, President Obama exposed himself to the demagoguery of Republican primary opponents with his own apology. Why does the violence continue?

For the professionally clueless (and by this I mean the people in the insider press and the consensus peddlers in D.C.), let's make this simple:

  1. The specific offense is a deeply serious affront to highly conservative Afghan sensibilities. Can you imagine what would happen at Pastor John Hagee's church the day after an Islamic military force stationed in San Antonio set a stack of Christian Bibles on fire?
  2.  

  3. More importantly, the Koran burnings ignited a highly volatile mix of hostility created over years of constant offenses inherent in a long-term occupation and the specifics of U.S. military policies in Afghanistan. As anyone who's ever been in any kind of relationship will tell you, saying sorry when you do wrong is necessary, but when your partner knows the bad behaviors will continue, sorry doesn't cut it.

 

The military forces in Afghanistan is well aware of the factors generating such intense anti-American hostility. Here's an excerpt from a declassified http://www.gwu.edu/~nsarchiv/NSAEBB/NSAEBB370/docs/Document%2011.pdf">U.S. Army report from 2011 (.pdf) focusing just on the anti-Americanism rampant in the Afghan National Security Forces (ANSF) we're paying to train:

ANSF members identified numerous social, cultural and operational grievances they have with US.  Soldiers.  Factors that created animosity were reviewed through a content analysis that measured frequency and intensity of  the perceived grievances.  Factors that fueled the most animosity included US.  convoys not allowing traffic to  pass, reportedly indiscriminant [sic] return U.S. fire that causes civilian casualties, naively using flawed intelligence sources, US.  Forces conducting night raids/home searches, violating female privacy during searches, US.  road blocks, publicly searching/disarming ANSF members as an SOP when they enter bases, and past massacres of  civilians by U.S. Forces (i.e., the Wedding Party Massacre, the Shinwar Massacre, etc.).  Other issues that led to altercations or near~altercations (including many self-reported near - fratricide incidents) included urinating in public, their cursing at, insulting and being rude and vulgar to ANSF members, and unnecessarily shooting animals.  They found many U.S. Soldiers to be extremely arrogant, bullying, unwilling to listen to their advice, and were often seen as lacking concern for civilian and ANSF safety during combat.  CAT 1 interpreters' (n=30)views were similar to the ANSF's.

 

For the record, the feeling is mutual:

U.S. Soldiers' (n=215) views of  ANSF, particularly of  the ANA, were also collected; they were extremely negative.  They reported pervasive illicit drug use, massive thievery, personal instability, dishonesty, no integrity, incompetence, unsafe weapons handling, corrupt officers, no real NCO corps, covert alliances/informal treaties with insurgents, high AWOL rates, bad morale, laziness, repulsive hygiene and the torture of  dogs.  Perceptions of civilians were also negative stemming from their insurgent sympathies and cruelty towards women and children.

 

So here we have a war that's lasted longer than a decade, peddled to the public and the politicians as primarily a war for "hearts and minds" in which our "local partners" would be built up and handed a country as we declare victory. Only, it turns out that after all this time, all these lives, and all this money, not only have we not won over the Afghan street, we've not even won over the hearts and minds of the people we're giving guns and paychecks. Sorry--"not won over" is an amazing understatement. Not only have we not won over the ANSF, but a great many of them are killing U.S. military officers. In many cases, they're killing the officers training them. The Army's report goes on to disclose, emphasis ours:

Of note, during the last six month period (November, 2010 through April, 2011) Westerners stationed within Afghanistan's N2KL region (Nangarhar, Nuristan, Kunar  and Laghman provinces) who regularly interact and/or train with ANSFs have been over 150 times more likely to be murdered by an ANSF member than a U.S. police officer is to be murdered in the line of duty by all perpetrators (see Appendix B, pg.  59 for calculation); this excludes the additional risks associated with regular combat for  these coalition personnel.  Further, such ANSF fratricide-murders represent 30% of  all U.S. field grade officer hostile deaths in Afghanistan (7 of 23), 25% of all hostile U.S. female military deaths (4 of 16) and over 50% of all hostile U.S.A.F. officer deaths (7 of  13).

 

...However, the common refrain from many ISAF political and military officials has been that such murder incidents between ANSF and ISAF are ''isolated'' and "extremely rare."  Such proclamations seem disingenuous, if not profoundly intellectually dishonest.

 

As we at Brave New Foundation have been saying for years through our http://facebook.com/RethinkAfghanistan">Rethink Afghanistan project, the Afghanistan War isn't making us safer and it's not worth the cost. In fact, the military-first policy in Afghanistan is so extraordinarily broken that it leads to http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2106305/Afghanistan-2-US-troops-killed-Koran-burning-protests-continue.html">U.S. military officers sitting in the middle of heavily guarded Afghan ministries being killed execution style before their killers apparently just walk out the door unmolested by their colleagues working in largely U.S.-funded government jobs.

Any politician standing in the way of a highly accelerated withdrawal--the blindingly obvious right move--deserves a taxpayer funded paycheck about as much as Hamid Karzai or a security guard at the Afghan interior ministry. For God's sake, get out and bring our troops, our money and our attention home.

Join Brave New Foundation's http://facebook.com/warcosts">War Costs campaign to help get our troops and our dollars home.

Follow http://twitter.com/robertgreenwald">Robert Greenwald and http://twitter.com/derrickcrowe">Derrick Crowe on Twitter.

 

http://bravenewfilms.org/

Robert Greenwald is a producer, director and political activist; the founder and president of Brave New Films, a new media company that uses moving images to educate, influence, and empower viewers to take action around issues that matter. Under (more...)
 
Share on Google Plus Submit to Twitter Add this Page to Facebook! Share on LinkedIn Pin It! Submit to Reddit Submit to Stumble Upon

The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.

Writers Guidelines

Contact Author Contact Editor View Authors' Articles

Most Popular Articles by this Author:     (View All Most Popular Articles by this Author)

Is your Senator Representing Charles and David Koch?

Inside the Koch Brothers' Expensive Echo Chamber

Are the Koch brothers teaching you?

Want to see how the Kochs are ending public education?

In the lead: Rupert Murdoch and the Koch Brothers

What the Koch brothers say online but won't say under oath

Comments

The time limit for entering new comments on this article has expired.

This limit can be removed. Our paid membership program is designed to give you many benefits, such as removing this time limit. To learn more, please click here.

Comments: Expand   Shrink   Hide  
1 people are discussing this page, with 1 comments
To view all comments:
Expand Comments
(Or you can set your preferences to show all comments, always)

that the US is crying wolf and after several or mo... by Archie on Wednesday, Feb 29, 2012 at 11:10:48 PM