Dahlia Wasfi, MD (photo by Mac McKinney)
I ended Part 3 of my series on Dr. Dahlia Wasfi with glimpses into her powers of observation and analysis of the strategies underlying the American-led Coalition's attempted pacification of Iraq, which to this day is still suffering from brutal internecine warfare. In this piece we will explore this and the effects of the war on Iraqi society more thoroughly, but first we must recount Dahlia's reflections on her second trip to war-torn Iraq.
Basra during the American occupation (Photobucket Commons)
But I have never - I got sick while I was there - been so sick in my entire life, and I literally told my [Iraqi] family, and this will be in the book [Dahlia is writing a book on her experiences - Mac], since I thought I was going to die, please tell my parents a good story. Tell them I attacked the British. Tell them I was a martyr, but please don't tell them I died from diarrhea, please that would be the worst thing. And all I could think about at the time were the stories I read from after the first Gulf War when cholera became endemic in Iraq, and I read an account of somebody saying there's nothing worse than dehydrating to death and the only water you have to drink is the same dirty water that made you sick, and I felt so lucky when I was there - I had access to bottled water; I had access to antibiotics, but oh my God, I've never been so sick! Everyone in the Administration should have to have a bout of some GI pathogen like that to see what they're doing to people. That was hard for me to come to terms with. So it was basically my personal experiences, basically my version of Survivor.
But for my family, there was no way out. This is what they had to live with everyday...and I tell you...the two times that I have gone have been in the wintertime. I tell my family that I will never visit you in the summer because I will lay down on the floor and die. In Basra especially, because they have the humidity from the....river, the waterway, it gets to be over a 115 degrees Fahrenheit plus humidity. And they don't have the electricity to run a ceiling fan, let alone air-conditioning .
Mac: Wow, 115!
Dahlia: On a good day, on a good day. You know, for someone like me, this is going to make me livid. If I had the energy for any emotion, it would make me furious and angry, but for old people, people with heart conditions, asthmatics, diabetics, for the little babies who are prone to the diarrheal diseases, this is deadly. This is deadly. And this is another reason why the death toll is so high, because when they do the calculations for say the Lancet Studies, it's overall what is the increased number of deaths, not just from military assault.....
Mac: Is cholera epidemic now, or just endemic?
Dahlia: It's considered endemic now. They still have epidemic episodes. The last one I know of was 2007. That's the last one I've documented, that I found the research on.
Mac: What about women's rights in Iraq right now?
Dahlia: We have set them back for decades if not centuries. And this is under the auspices of the new government, which is CIA-coordinated, but basically, prior to American involvement, Iraq was one of the most progressive countries in that part of the world in terms of women's rights, marital rights, property rights, educated women. Part of that can be attributed to [secular government], and I again have to make the qualifier that there's no question of the brutality of the dictatorship - if you became political you took your life and your family's life into your hands; you didn't know if you would be jailed, tortured....but first of all, there was free eduction, and everybody had access to it, and it was also a secular government, and it tends to be - when religion is involved in government - there tends to be a decline in women's rights, with more conservative leadership, but with a more secular government, that kind of restriction on women's rights did not happen, but also during the 1980s there was the Iran-Iraq War, and instead of bringing in foreign workers to replace the men who had left for war, they trained women, so that strenghtened the country itself. It's like what happened here in World War II when the women started to take the jobs in the factories. So women were in every aspect of society. Once we invaded, a big factor in the loss of women's rights was the influx of religious militias, religious groups and militias, from Iran [many of them having gone into exile under Saddam Hussein - Mac]........
Women and children in Iraq (Photobucket Commons)
There are numerous militias, numerous parties that have moved in, based in Iran, and with the militias have come the loss of women's rights - restrictions on women's dress, restrictions on covering your hair, restrictions on wearing makeup. Now I don't mean to be critical, and I have to qualify this because I personally don't cover my hair....it's not my choice - but ever woman should have her choice, and in Iraq now since the invasion, they don't have a choice anymore.
My cousins told me a story because my cousins in the south, they tell me stories of women getting harassed for not covering their hair, of women getting harassed for wearing makeup, and now it's become more and more difficult for women to attend university. Everything was co-ed. Now they're trying to separate out the sexes, so this influence came in since the invasion, and then with the new constitution, that opened the door for the use of Sharia Law, which again, depending on interpretation - and I'm not trying to be critical of Islam, but it's men who wrote it down and it's mostly men who are doing the interpretation - it opens the door for the loss of property rights and marital rights. And now there are between one and two million widows in Iraq, and with that, when you count as an orphan someone who has lost one or both parents, four to five million orphans [estimated], so we have devastated Iraq for the next generation at least. So this is the bottom line. This is the tragedy.
These revelations by Dahlia certainly put a damper on more positive spins of the consequences of the Bush/Cheney invasion of Iraq. Even though the United States has allocated some 53 billion dollars to the reconstruction of Iraq, more than we spent on the reconstruction of Germany and Japan combined after World War II (even adjusting for inflation over time) progress overall is "spotty" at best in terms of stability, economic prosperity, human rights improvements and a society healing from the wounds of war. Yes, the backbone of the Iraqi economy, the oil sector, is gradually reviving, but there are still millions of Iraqis in external or internal exile, gross unemployment hovering, some reports say, around 30%, perhaps higher, perhaps lower. The huge number of widows and orphans, as Dahlia has mentioned, create a social nightmare for the present and the future, and terrorist bombs are still going off in Baghdad and elsewhere. Even an American convoy was hit as recently as June 23 in an attack that killed "international development and finance expert Dr. Stephen Everhart and wounded three others." (source)
The Center for American Progress published an article and report entitled "The Iraq War Ledger, A Tabulation of the Human, Financial, and Strategic Costs" in May, 2010 that tallies up all the then costs and benefits, human, financial and otherwise in terms of American national security, and it is not a very pretty picture at all. You can read the pdf report HERE. To quote from some of the study's conclusions:
Seven years after that speech, Iraq has made progress, but still struggles with terrorism and deep political discord. Though the level of violence has declined from its 2006-07 peak--when dozens of bodies could be found on Baghdad's streets every morning--Iraq still endures a level of violence that anywhere else in the world would be considered a crisis. Still, the end of Saddam Hussein's brutal regime represents a considerable global good, and a nascent democratic Iraqi republic allied with the United States could potentially yield benefits in the future.
But when weighing those possible benefits against the costs of the Iraq intervention, there is simply no conceivable calculus by which Operation Iraqi Freedom can be judged to have been a successful or worthwhile policy. The war was intended to show the extent of America's power. It succeeded only in showing its limits. (.ibid)
A key strategic cost worth emphasizing from the same report is this:
Loss of moral authority. While abuses are perhaps inevitable in any military occupation, the images and stories broadcast from Iraq into the region and around the world have done lasting damage to the United States' reputation as a supporter of international order and human rights. Gen. David Petraeus acknowledges the damage done to the U.S. reputation by Abu Ghraib is permanent, calling it a "nonbiodegradable" event.As Dahlia has already noted in previous statements in this series, the US Government stepped over into the dark side, as was also done, for example, in Vietnam and elsewhere to try to secure, if not victory at least "stability" in a target country. But how, as ethicists keep asking, can the ends justify the means when the means taint and subvert the ends, if not becoming the ends altogether? And this is where we must talk more about death squads and the Salvador Option in Iraq and how they wrecked further havoc, with yet unfinished consequences in that country.
Mac: Let's talk about death squads. I think I read that you were mentioning the Wolf Brigade. And I am also curious as to how many of these terrorist bombings might have been by the Americans and British.
Dahlia: I don't know, but the question is an important one. But you really did your homework. I referenced the Wolf Brigade, which was a brigade I believe I am correct in stating was a brigade in the Iraqi police that was basically organized by someone who was a high-ranking general under Saddam, and then became a high-ranking general under Donald Rumsfeld. The name was General Rashid Flayyih. But my resource for that is a journalist named Max Fuller. He's from Wales. He's done remarkable work that actually has shown that Operation Phoenix in Vietnam has been brought back.
Mac: Oh yeah, we've learned about that, the Salvador Option.
Death squads in Iraq (Photobucket Commons)
[For a riveting video and Max Fuller article posted right below it giving an in-depth look at death squads in Iraq, VISIT HERE.]
Dahlia: That's it.....Max Fuller has done like a fantastic fifteen minute video on the internet (Who is behind the death Squads in Iraq). But you may have heard of how in September 2005 in Basra there was a suspicious car that the Iraqi police approached, and when the police approached the car, the people in the car shot at the policemen, so they were detained immediately and brought to the police station, and what they found in the car was were that these two guys were British Special Operations.
1 | 2