New York City -- Activists from Witness Against Torture support the release of five men from GuantÃ¡namo to monitored residence in Qatar in exchange for the American POW Bowe Bergdahl. While freeing an American captive, the exchange advances the important goals of closing GuantÃ¡namo and helping Afghanistan achieve peace after the planned withdrawal of most US forces. The US must now expedite the release of the 78 detained men already cleared for transfer, plan for the transfer of others, and find a just resolution to the fate of all the men held at GuantÃ¡namo.
Witness Against Torture also decries the politically motivated lies and distortions surrounding the prisoner exchange, which wrongly portray all the men at GuantÃ¡namo as security risks to the United States and may make closing the prison even more difficult. The political attacks also obscure a vital aspect of the prisoner exchange: facilitating negotiations with the Taliban over the future of Afghanistan, which both the United States and Afghan governments seek.
"As Bush administration official John Bellinger has written," says Witness Against Torture's Matt Daloisio, "there is no legal justification for holding the so-called 'Taliban 5' after the end of major military operations in Afghanistan in a prison that should have never have existed. Their release to Qatar is part of the conclusion of a phase of armed conflict, consistent with the ways nations have drawn down wars."
"We can't forget the many men trapped in GuantÃ¡namo who are not considered 'important' enough to be part of a political deal," adds activist Palina Prasasouk. "Those already cleared for transfer demand our immediate attention. Freeing them is what the nation should be talking about."
"The great danger in the hysteria surrounding the prisoner swap -- cynically stoked by the political right to further demonize President Obama -- is that GuantÃ¡namo stays open indefinitely," says Jeremy Varon of Witness Against Torture. "Any effort to increase congressional restrictions on the transfer of detainees must be resisted. GuantÃ¡namo remains a place of imprisonment without charge or trial, hunger strikes, and continued torture through brutal forced feeding. Obama's own record on GuantÃ¡namo has been poor, although in the last year we have finally seen some real commitment to closing the prison. That members of Congress and the media are now calling for GuantÃ¡namo to remain open forever is completely unacceptable. We can't return to the worst days of the Bush administration, when fear-mongering and callous disregard for the rule of law, the facts, and human rights drove US policy. GuantÃ¡namo must close. Period. Full stop."
Formed in 2005, Witness Against Torture is the leading, grassroots human rights organization dedicated to closing GuantÃ¡namo and ending indefinite detention. Its activities include educational events, demonstrations, non-violent civil disobedience, and the co-ordination of global solidarity fasts.