“... the dilemma CIA directors and senior intelligence professionals face in cases when they know that unvarnished intelligence judgments will not be welcomed by the President, his policy managers, and his political advisers...[They] must decide whether to tell it like it is (and so risk losing their place at the President’s advisory table), or to go with the flow of existing policy by accentuating the positive (thus preserving their access and potential influence). In these episodes from the Vietnam era, we have seen that senior CIA officers more often than not tended toward the latter approach.” “CIA and the Vietnam Policymakers: Three Episodes, 1962-1968” Harold P. Ford
Bummer. I wish there were more of a sense of anger at that.
Back to Iran. This time, we all know that the president and vice president are seeking an excuse to attack Iran. There is a big difference from the situation in the summer of 1964, when President Johnson had intimidated all his senior subordinates into using deceit to escalate the war. Bamford comments on the disingenuousness of Robert McNamara when he testified in 1968 that it was “inconceivable” that senior officials, including the president, deliberately used the Tonkin Gulf events to generate Congressional support for a wider Vietnam war.
In Bamford’s words, the Joint Chiefs of Staff had become “a sewer of deceit,” with Operation Northwoods and other unconscionable escapades to its credit. Then-Under Secretary of State George Ball commented, “There was a feeling that if the destroyer got into some trouble, that this would provide the provocation we needed.”
Good News: It’s Different Now
As indicated above, we now have more integrity at the top of the intelligence community. But, in my view, the main thing that has prevented Bush and Cheney from attacking Iran so far has been the strong opposition of the uniformed military, including the Joint Chiefs. The circumstances attending the misadventure last Sunday in the Strait of Hormuz are far from clear. But the incident certainly shows that our senior military need all the help they can get from intelligence officers more concerned with the truth than with “keeping lines open to the White House” and doing its bidding.
In addition, today the intelligence oversight committees in Congress seem to be waking from their Rip Van Winkle-like slumber. It was Congress, after all, that ordered the controversial NIE on Iran/nuclear (and was among those pushing strongly that it be publicized). And the flow of substantive intelligence to Congress is much larger than it was in 1964 when, remember, there were no intelligence committees as such.
So listen, you inheritors of the honorable profession of current intelligence, don’t let them grind you down. If you’re working in the bowels of the agency and you find that your leaders are cooking intelligence to a recipe for casus belli, think long and hard about the oath you took to protect the Constitution of the United States from all enemies, foreign and domestic.” Should not that oath transcend in importance any secrecy promise you had to agree to as a condition of employment?
By sticking your neck out, you might be able to prevent ten years of unnecessary war. This article appeared first on Consortiumnews.com.
Ray McGovern works with Tell the Word, the publishing arm of the ecumenical Church of the Saviour in Washington, DC. During his 27-years as a CIA analyst, he chaired NIEs: he is now on the Steering Group of Veteran Intelligence Professionals for Sanity (VIPS).
I READ THE ARTICLE, AND THEN I KNEW IT WAS YOU WHEN I SAW YOUR NAME! MAN IF WE COULD ONLY HAVE MANY MORE WHO CARED ABOUT PEOPLE AND THEIR COUNTRY STAND AND BE HEARD, THESE WIZARDS WOULD DISSAPEAR! WHEN YOU (CALLED OUT) RUMSFELD IN ATLANTA,IT TOOK ME AWHILE TO PICK MY JAW UP. A TRUE PATRIOT IN DEED. IF IT WASN'T FOR PEOPLE LIKE YOU AND (RON PAUL), I'D LOOSE ALL HOPE! THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING YOU DO!!!!!!!!MABE NOAH WILL COME GET US BEFORE WE COMPLETELY GO UNDER WATER FOR GOOD...I'LL KEEP THE LIGHT SHINING FOR THOSE LOST, TO HELP GUIDE....AGAIN.....THANK YOU.......VOTE....RON PAUL
by
BreakingThruTheCracks (0 articles, 0 quicklinks, 0 diaries, 3 comments)
on Sunday, January 13, 2008 at 9:50:21 AM
