Biren-Wright, along with the other five women, was held for 14 hours. At 5 a.m., she says, they were released from the "Roundhouse" onto a dark and barren street--there were no taxis anywhere near--and locked out of the police station. Although the women had cell phones, they had not been allowed to call for rides while in the jail area. Outside, they called friends, but waited until help arrived. Marini was released from the district jail later that morning.
The only reason Biren-Wright's pictures of the demonstration survived is because she had secretly removed the memory chip during the arrest. When the camera was finally returned, "all of the settings were messed up and the lens was not replaced properly."
The Army closed the AEC at the end of the pilot program. It had claimed that because of increased enlistments nationwide, the Center was no longer needed. It never acknowledged that the protestors and the public reaction may have been a reason for the closing.
In an unrelated case, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit ruled in October 2010 [Kelly v. Borough of Carlisle] that recording police activity in public places is protected by Constitutional guarantees. This month, the ACLU settled a case, for $48,500, in Pittsburgh when a University of Pittsburgh police officer arrested Elijah Matheny and charged him with felony violation of the state's Wiretap Act for using a cell phone to record police activity. Matheny spent a night in jail following his arrest. [See: Matheny v. County of Allegheny, et al.] The ACLU charged that the district attorney's office "had engaged in a pattern of erroneously advising law enforcement that audio taping police officers in public violates Pennsylvania's Wiretap Act." Following the Third Circuit's decision in the Kelly case, a conviction against Matheny is expected to be overturned.
The arrests in Philadelphia, Carlisle, and Pittsburgh underscores two major problems, both prevalent throughout the country. The first problem is a lack of understanding and respect for the Constitution by a large number, although not a majority, of police officers. For that reason, all police forces and district attorneys offices, from small isolated rural communities to the largest urban departments, need to have constant education about civil rights and Constitutional guarantees--and the penalties for violating those rights.
The second major problem is inherent within the mass media. Reporters need to know how and when to challenge authority to protect their own and the public's rights. A camera crew from the PBS "Frontline" series was at the protest, but abruptly stopped recording the demonstration after Brower was arrested and either before or during Biren-Wright's arrest. Rob Kall later said that a member of the "Frontline" crew told him the police informed them they would be arrested if they continued to film the demonstration.
Police threats, which violate Constitutional guarantees, place a "chilling effect" upon the media to observe and record actions by public officials. Even without a direct order by a public official, reporters may do what they perceive to be what others want them to do. The media, like police and public officials, also need constant education to know when police orders are lawful and when they are not. An order to move away from a scene may be lawful. An order to stop filming a scene upon threat of arrest is not.
In federal court, in the case of Biren v. City of Philadelphia, et al., these issues, and others, will be raised. But had there been an understanding of the Constitution by the police, the case would never have gotten to the point of a federal civil suit.
"OpEdNews Reporter Arrested While Photographing Demonstration,"
by Rob Kall; OpEdNews; Sept. 14, 2009.
"OpedNews Journalist and Six Protesters Charged With Criminal Conspiracy After Arrest At Army Experience Center," by Linda Milazzo; OpEdNews ; Sept. 14, 2009.
"Reporter Arrested While Photographing Protest at Army Experience Center," by Rob Kall; Huffington Post; Sept. 14, 2009
"Reporter, Six Protesters Charged With Criminal Conspiracy," by Jason Leopold; The Public Record; Sept. 14, 2009.
"The Army Experience Center's Bad Experience: Turns out Training Kids to Kill Not Popular with Public," by David Swanson; The Humanist; November/December 2009.