Meanwhile, Muslim charities report a precipitous decline in contributions. Contributions that do arrive come increasingly in cash from anonymous givers. And donors who happen to be Muslim are increasingly turning to the large household names like Oxfam and Save the Children, which may conduct programs in predominantly Muslim areas abroad.
Kay Guinane, OMB Watch 's Director of Nonprofit Speech Rights, told IPS, "The real tragedy behind closure of Muslim charities is the fate of people in need of humanitarian assistance, who are doing without because the funds have been frozen by the U.S. and sit in the bank, benefiting no one ". She suggested, "The U.S. government could demonstrate its good faith by releasing these funds to other charities or aid agencies."
Leaders of the Muslim charitable community in the U.S. have had numerous meetings with officials at the Treasury Department, and together developed a set of "guidelines " for charitable organizations and their donors. But these guidelines lack any specificity regarding Muslim philanthropy and could be applied to any charitable organization. They also provide no safe harbor from being shut down. OMB Watch told IPS, "A group could comply 100% and still be shut down 'pending an investigation '."
Leaders of the Muslim philanthropic community in New Jersey asked the Treasury Department at the start of Ramadan in 2004 to issue a "white list " of "approved " charities. But the request was denied. The government claimed it was impossible to fulfill. "Our role is to prosecute violations of criminal law, " a spokesman said, adding, "We 're not in a position to put out lists of any kind, particularly of any organizations that are good or bad "
But government critics also claim that Treasury 's campaign is reminiscent of the activities of John Ashcroft 's Justice Department in the months following the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001 on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon. The government then launched its "Global War on Terror " by rounding up thousands of "Middle Eastern-looking " men and women, sending them to jail without charges or access to lawyers, holding many in solitary confinement, but accusing none of them with terror-related crimes, convicting no one, and ending up deporting some for non-criminal immigration violations.
1 | 2
