Tags for This Article:

Government (3424) 

Populum Tag Cloud
       Control Panel
Fine tune your search to access content
Articles
Diaries Products
Events All
All time
Last 6 mos
Last month
Last week
Last 24 hrs
From:
Month  Day   Year

To:
Month  Day   Year
Alphabet
Popularity
Count ON
Count OFF
This Level
Sub-levels

 

 

 

Tag(s):
Add to My Group
April 20, 2007 at 12:15:25

The US Dilemma: Do we share the burden of Turks, or support our current ally--the Kurds?

by Aram Azez     Page 2 of 2 page(s)

www.opednews.com

 

Tell A Friend

View Ratings | Rate It  

The Armenian Genocide – Another controversial issue for  

Turkey 

 According to PanArmenian.net, a group of prominent Armenians and Turks initiated a third-party study in 2002 of the procedures of 1915-1918 when they equally came up to the International Center for Transitional Justice (ICTJ). In a comprehensive report, the New York-based organization fulfilled that the Armenian massacres included “all of the elements of the crime of genocide” as distinct by a 1948 United Nations convention. The Armenian Genocide Resolution (S. Res. 106) calls upon George W. Bush to ensure that the foreign policy of the United States reflects suitable sympathy and sensitivity regarding issues related to human rights, ethnic cleansing, and genocide recognized in the United States evidence relating to the Armenian Genocide.  

U.S. President George W. Bush has also cited the ICTJ study in his annual messages to the Armenian-American community. Bush’s most recent statements called it “a significant contribution toward deepening our understanding of these events”. However, both the US defense secretary and US Secretary of State have sent a letter to senior members of the US Congress indicating the damage that Turkish-US ties could suffer if the pending resolution on Armenian claims of genocide at the hands of the Ottoman Turks is passed.

“It is no secret that the strategic relationship between the United States and Turkey has undergone some turbulence in recent years,” Gates said, in his first public speech after becoming Secretary of Defense. It was not by accident that he spoke at a Turkish-American event, Gates said, adding that Turkey and the United States should avoid  damaging attitudes, such as the Armenian genocide resolution pending at the US Congress and the worsening anti-American stance in Turkey. 

Human rights and freedom of expression violations  

Despite the escalating pressure by the European Union on Turkey – an EU-hopeful country – regarding freedom of expression, in recent years, hundreds of politicians, writers, journalists and academics have been prosecuted in Turkey for expressing their views. Among them were 2006 Nobel Prize winner, Orhan Pamuk and renowned Turkish novelist Elif Shafak. According to Turkey’s Article 301, mentioning the Armenian genocide or raising the Kurdish issue or praising Kurdish leaders, are criminal offenses. According to this notorious Article, criticizing Turkey in any way is considered “denigrating Turkishness or undermining Turkey’s national unity.”

A 92-year-old retired Turkish archaeologist, Muazzez Ilmiye Cig, who is also an expert on the ancient Sumerian civilization of Mesopotamia, has claimed in one of her books that the headscarf worn by Muslim women was first used by women in ancient Sumerian era – for pre-Islamic sexual rites. She went on trial in Turkey for expressing her views, which the government considered “insulting Islam.”

In recent years, hundreds of prominent Kurdish politicians and intellectuals have faced charges for referring to Abdullah Ocalan as honorific, or simply for having raised the Kurdish issue. Current Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan, himself, was accused of referring to Ocalan as "Sayin" or esteemed in an interview in 2000. Prosecutors examined recordings of the comments, but found him not guilty.

On March 6, a Turkish court ordered blocking access to You Tube because of videos allegedly insulting Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, the founder of the modern Turkish state. Many Kurdish-English websites, newspapers, and TV channels are also being banned in Turkey – something that George Bernard Shaw of the New York Times called “the extreme form of censorship”.  EU skepticism over an Islamic Turkish government 

The skepticism of the European Union towards the efforts of Turkey's Islamist government to meet the EU standards has much elevated. Turkey has been at the center of the altercation between Islamism and freedom of speech. Scientists say religious Muslims in the government, that has its roots in political Islam, are trying to push Turkish education away from its traditionally secular approach.

Reuters newly noticed: Now here's a hilarious conundrum for the idiot left that cheers on reactionary Islamism as heroic anti-imperialism. Are we supposed to oppose this garbage when conservative Christians do it in the US, but support it when conservative Muslims do it in Turkey?

Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan has met and invited his Palestinian counterpart Ismail Haniya of the hardliner Islamist Hamas movement to visit Ankara. Haniya heads the new Palestinian government that includes Hamas, which is regarded as a terrorist group by Israel and the West. Turkey also has strong relations with Iran, which nowadays is almost an isolated regime in the international community, especially in relations with the US and its allies.

Turkish Islamist administration was annoyed by an EU mug in Brussels last March. The mug was offered to the French President by German Chancellor Angela Merkel at the last European Union summit, but Turkish media said the lid of the mug portrayed the 1799 defeat of Turkish forces by Napoleon in Egypt. Although Turks are sensitive nationalists in the matter of their related issues, experts believe that the recent reaction by Turkish Foreign Minister was likely religion-related.

Another crucial trouble of Turkey with the EU is Cyprus. Last December, the EU suspended talks in 8 of the 35 areas because of Ankara's refusal to open its ports and airports to traffic from Cyprus, an EU member that Turkey does not recognize.

Now, it is still up to the US to decide whether to share Turkey’s heavy burden, which includes political, military, and financial assistance to overcome its ‘Kurd-phobia,’ the Armenian genocide, the Cyrus issue, the human rights violations, trouble joining the EU and so forth. Or, to support its’ new and loyal Kurdish ally in Kurdistan on which the Americans can depend without facing any hostilities and where, from the beginning of the Iraq War up to now – not a single US soldier has died.

 1  |  2

 

www.newand.net

Aram Azez is a Kurdish Political Journalist. He writes about the Kurdish  and    Middle East Issues in both Kurdish and English languages. Most of his articles are published in Kurdish-English Newspapers and Websites(see www.kurdishmedia.com for his articles in English .) Currently he is editor-in chief of printed Kurdish Newspaper, Newand .

Contact Author
Contact Editor
View Other Articles by Author

 

Bookmark this page: (what's this?)

NETSCAPE      DIGG THIS      Add This Page to Mr Wong!           NEWSVINE      DEl.ICIO.US      Looksmart Furl      My Web      Tag!RawSugar      Blink List     (More...)
Comments: Expand   Shrink   Hide  
11 comments

The author lives in a small village in central Europe and has been active in the local workers movement for nearly 3 decades.

Globalism knows no borders, why should we ?

Tony ForestThe author lives in a small village in central Europe and has been active in the local workers movement for nearly 3 decades.

Globalism knows no borders, why should we ?

Good question

A very good question. Rest assured, our most trustworthy Govt. in Washington D.C. will do the right thing because doing the right thing is the right thing to do. Besides, they're top-heavy with experts like Rice.

It doesn't take an expert to read which side the Author is on. I miss equal representation of the good people of Turkey in this articlle and I don't for one minute believe the US Govt. can make a right decision in this matter for one simple reason : it's not our war. Kurdistan was on the table before 9/11. Uh, let me re-phrase let ; plans on "how to react to the Kurdistan / PKK / Ankara issue once Iraq is toppled once we have the excuse to get in there and do what has to be done" were made prior to 9/11. If you don't believe it, you're fooling yourself. And then there's Israel. In all fareness, you really need to mention each and every clan, not just the big players ....just to be fare. You'd have to roll it all back and go into detail about who killed who, when and why and who own what and why. It's a friggin' bee's nest !

I would like to know what the author thinks about what this other author has written on the subject ;


and I invite the author to participate in the discussion. My attempt at opening a discussion on this very subject ;

http://www.opednews.com/maxwrite/diarypage.php?did=3315

by Tony Forest (7 articles, 18 quicklinks, 166 diaries, 1429 comments) on Friday, April 20, 2007 at 1:24:19 PM
 


Aram Azez is a Kurdish Political Journalist. He writes about the Kurdish  and    Middle East Issues in both Kurdish and English languages. Most of his articles are published in Kurdish-English Newspapers and Websites(see www.kurdishmedia.com for his articles in English .) Currently he is editor-in chief of printed Kurdish Newspaper, Newand .
AramAram Azez is a Kurdish Political Journalist. He writes about the Kurdish  and    Middle East Issues in both Kurdish and English languages. Most of his articles are published in Kurdish-English Newspapers and Websites(see www.kurdishmedia.com for his articles in English .) Currently he is editor-in chief of printed Kurdish Newspaper, Newand .

a brief answer

Well, thanks for the comment and your question, rossini.

 

 As for other parts of Kurdistan, particularly, Iran, the US doesn’t share any of Iran’s burdens. But it does for Turkey. And the problem with Turkey is, it considers itself as an old ally to the US, asks too much, but offers nothing! And I have not mentioned the people of Turkey; it is all about the regime not the people.

 

As for the PKK issue, it is not today’s question. It is one of Turkey’s problems which it denies for decades- it is the Kurdish issue. PKK has been there for 2 decades, Turkish army couldn’t do as much as it whishes to. The question is why Turkey now is too much concerned about the PKK issue?

 

As for what I think of other writer’s regarding the same subject, it depends on who the writer is, or from which points of view and information he/ she writes.  Is he/ she just reflecting what Turkish, Arab, Iranian regimes saying-or do they have sufficient knowledge about the situation and elaborating?

 

I, myself, have been mentoring the Kurdish issue-got involved in it- for more than 3 decades, and I know which point I’m talking about.

by Aram (3 articles, 0 quicklinks, 0 diaries, 9 comments) on Friday, April 20, 2007 at 3:59:38 PM
 


The author lives in a small village in central Europe and has been active in the local workers movement for nearly 3 decades.

Globalism knows no borders, why should we ?

Tony ForestThe author lives in a small village in central Europe and has been active in the local workers movement for nearly 3 decades.

Globalism knows no borders, why should we ?

Thanks for engaging

Aram, check out what jhritz on dailykos has to say about the situation. I'm not sure which side of the fence he's on but he does seem to be an expert on this Kurdish issue. Use the links I mentioned above and look at what jhritz has had to say. I think the part that suprised me most was where jhritz noted ....

"Relax People...The Iraqi Kurds and the Turks have.....

a longstanding understanding about the PKK, no matter how much saber rattling goes on between Erdogan and Barzani... sigh.

The Turks cross the border all the time to go after the PKK camps. They couldn't do that without permission from the Iraqi KRG (Kurdish Regional Govt) and that means repeated deals between the Talabani/Bazani clans and Turkey that marks the PKK as forfeit. They've gone after them, individually and TOGETHER in the past.

See this comment for a complete analysis of the Turkish/Kurdish border situation.

They're pragmatists.

And see my sig line for a complete diary on the Kurds.

Relax."

 

 

 

by Tony Forest (7 articles, 18 quicklinks, 166 diaries, 1429 comments) on Saturday, April 21, 2007 at 2:35:19 AM
 


Aram Azez is a Kurdish Political Journalist. He writes about the Kurdish  and    Middle East Issues in both Kurdish and English languages. Most of his articles are published in Kurdish-English Newspapers and Websites(see www.kurdishmedia.com for his articles in English .) Currently he is editor-in chief of printed Kurdish Newspaper, Newand .
AramAram Azez is a Kurdish Political Journalist. He writes about the Kurdish  and    Middle East Issues in both Kurdish and English languages. Most of his articles are published in Kurdish-English Newspapers and Websites(see www.kurdishmedia.com for his articles in English .) Currently he is editor-in chief of printed Kurdish Newspaper, Newand .

Thanks for the link and your interest in the Kurdish issue,

Although jhritz mostly relies on history and reads about the Kurdish issue from different sources, he indeed got a good sense about the Kurds. I hope I could meet him in person and have some discussions with him.

 

As for the member of Kurds, no one real knows who Kurds are exactly there in the world. All of us rely on either; those governments’ estimation which conquering Kurdistan. Or, rely on Kurds’ estimation, for which they rely on some non-official sources, such as: if in Amed alone, there are 2.5 million Kurds living; so there are at least 10 large Kurdish cities in Turkey—if there will be a million in each, plus in the Turkish cities there are many thousands—it would be reasonable to say some 30 million Kurds live under Turkey’s oppression.

But, do these regimes real want the world knows how many Kurds they have oppressed? Do we, Kurds, want reduce our under estimated member?

  

As for the PKK issue and US, the question is, has ever PKK hurt a US soldier, or any Americans not only in Kurdistan or Iraq, where you can see PKK presences in every city, but all over the world? The answer is NO. Can’t PKK attach the US interests? Yes, it can, but despite all the US negative approach towards PKK, it wants to approve that it has nothing with other countries; it is not a terrorist organization—all it does is demanding the Kurds’ rights in Turkey.

 

by Aram (3 articles, 0 quicklinks, 0 diaries, 9 comments) on Saturday, April 21, 2007 at 11:36:19 AM
 


The author lives in a small village in central Europe and has been active in the local workers movement for nearly 3 decades.

Globalism knows no borders, why should we ?

Tony ForestThe author lives in a small village in central Europe and has been active in the local workers movement for nearly 3 decades.

Globalism knows no borders, why should we ?

Satterfield warned Barzani

Looks like like this could come to a boil real quick. But if Rice & Satterfield think they can remain neutral, they're dead wrong. They stepped in it and now it's stuck to their shoes. Yuck.

by Tony Forest (7 articles, 18 quicklinks, 166 diaries, 1429 comments) on Saturday, April 21, 2007 at 9:00:47 AM
 


The author lives in a small village in central Europe and has been active in the local workers movement for nearly 3 decades.

Globalism knows no borders, why should we ?

Tony ForestThe author lives in a small village in central Europe and has been active in the local workers movement for nearly 3 decades.

Globalism knows no borders, why should we ?

in reply to your reply

you are most welcome. My interest in the Kurds began in a Döner Kebab Haus here in Germany, many years ago. The owner spoke broken German. He was a Kurd and said he was proud to be a Kurd. The other Turks in the shop were not Kurds. It was this slight contrast which sparked my interest. Coming from Kansas, I had never heard of the Kurds and I knew very little about Turkey. Then as the conversations progressed, I noticed I knew a few words of Turkish....all my life without realizing it. In the early 80s, I traveled to Turkey with a German friends. We explored Turkey day by day. Our exploration was an eye-opener. Once one the beach in Side, near Antalya...we met up with a Turkish Kurd named Apo. Apo and his family gave us shelter for three days while we learned all we could from them. One thing we learned will never be forgotten ; the word "politic" is a word one should never ever speak ...in Turkey. Now, decades later, I know more about the Kurds and once the USA illegally invaded Iraq, I called my German friend to tell him I thought the Kurdish war would find knew fuel and the Americans would find themselves in the middle of a very bad situation....but as our conversation went on and still continues, we both hope and pray that our friends the Kurds will find peace and a unity that has been long sought after. We're not only thinking of our Kurdish friends when we say this ; our Turkish ....non Kurdish friends want it too.

 

Selam 

by Tony Forest (7 articles, 18 quicklinks, 166 diaries, 1429 comments) on Saturday, April 21, 2007 at 2:42:09 PM
 


PhD candidate in Economics at the Middle East Technical University in Ankara
Tolga TuncerPhD candidate in Economics at the Middle East Technical University in Ankara

Turkey- Kurds- United States

Very one sided.  "Do we" ?? Are you an American citizen? It is ridiculous for me to see that the Kurds like you so much want to speak as if US and Kurds are "inseperable allies" and in a tone that is more American than an American. One simple fact to remind: Turkey is a big and influential country in the region and US-Turkey ties are much deeper and historical than it seems to you. There are currently problematic issues and these are mainly related to US presence in Iraq. US needs Kurds for their presence in Iraq safely. But be sure US is not going to stay in Iraq forever. So Kurds have to learn to live with Turkey not the other way around. (as well as Syria and Iran) So the best strategy for our Kurdish brothers is to stop offending their neighbours within the drunkness of unconditional American support and make more longer term plans. (Note : the number of people who declare themselves as "Kurds" is 13 Million in Turkey)

by Tolga Tuncer (0 articles, 0 quicklinks, 0 diaries, 2 comments) on Tuesday, April 24, 2007 at 3:01:53 AM
 


Aram Azez is a Kurdish Political Journalist. He writes about the Kurdish  and    Middle East Issues in both Kurdish and English languages. Most of his articles are published in Kurdish-English Newspapers and Websites(see www.kurdishmedia.com for his articles in English .) Currently he is editor-in chief of printed Kurdish Newspaper, Newand .
AramAram Azez is a Kurdish Political Journalist. He writes about the Kurdish  and    Middle East Issues in both Kurdish and English languages. Most of his articles are published in Kurdish-English Newspapers and Websites(see www.kurdishmedia.com for his articles in English .) Currently he is editor-in chief of printed Kurdish Newspaper, Newand .

Azorka,

Well, thanks for your notice anyways, you’re right it is on sided article and you can name me as a bias writer, more American than Americans, or whatsoever you like.  But as for today, it is reality that the Kurds are vital allies to the US while once again the Islamic regime in Ankara back stabs the Americans and demands more US support.

As whether the US stays in Iraq for ever or not--you have to realize that--   for the past several decades the US has had been supportive of the Turks, mainly against the Kurdish issue-- but have the Kurds ever turned against the Americans; or given up their struggle?

So, if the US stays or leaves Iraq, the best way for Turkey is to get over its Kurd phobia! This issue can not be solved by denial and oppressing. And why Kurds (as you claim to be 13 millions in Turkey) not talking about Iran, Syria, and Iraq, “have to learn to live with Turkey”?

Why it is rightful for others to have their own country (some of which built on Kurds lands) but Kurds have to live under their oppressive regimes and at their mercy?

by Aram (3 articles, 0 quicklinks, 0 diaries, 9 comments) on Tuesday, April 24, 2007 at 11:43:18 AM
 


PhD candidate in Economics at the Middle East Technical University in Ankara
Tolga TuncerPhD candidate in Economics at the Middle East Technical University in Ankara

living together in peace

Mr. Aram,

I totally agree that Kurds (as all the other ethnic groups living in Turkey) deserve any kind of rights within the context of law and Turkish citizenship.  Actually, the situation is not that bad as you would like to present. Kurdish citizens have the right to learn, speak and use their language. Have the right to publish and broadcast in Kurdish etc... There are difficulties with the implementation. But believe me this stems mainly from the terror threat.  I think you see how the atmosphere in the West changed after 9/11.  Even the most basic human rights are legally touchable now by the legislation like this "Patriot Act". We are living with the terror threat in Turkey for 20 years.  So, violence will never solve the problems but only make it worse.  I believe we need make a clear distinction between the two: Human and citizenship rights and ultra-nationalism. I say yes to all the rights to be given to our Kurdish citizens. But I say no to racist Kurdish nationalism which cost around 30000 lives to Turkey from both sides through PKK terror. (as I say also no to Turkish ultra-nationalism)

by Tolga Tuncer (0 articles, 0 quicklinks, 0 diaries, 2 comments) on Thursday, April 26, 2007 at 1:51:34 AM
 


Martin Zehr is an American political writer in the San Francisco area. He spent 8 years working as a volunteer water planner for the Middle Rio Grande region. http://www.waterassembly.org
His article on the Kirkuk Referendum has been printed by the Kurdish Regional Government, http://www.moera-krg.org/articles/detail.asp?smap=01030000&lngnr=12&anr=12121&rnr=140 Another article was reprinted in its entirety by the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK) http://www.puk.org/web/htm/news/nws/news0...

to see more of bio, click on member name

Martin ZehrMartin Zehr is an American political writer in the San Francisco area. He spent 8 years working as a volunteer water planner for the Middle Rio Grande region. http://www.waterassembly.org
His article on the Kirkuk Referendum has been printed by the Kurdish Regional Government, http://www.moera-krg.org/articles/detail.asp?smap=01030000&lngnr=12&anr=12121&rnr=140 Another article was reprinted in its entirety by the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK) http://www.puk.org/web/htm/news/nws/news0...

to see more of bio, click on member name

Supporting Kurdistan Through Thick and Thin

There are actions that can be taken by the US government in regards to upholding the Kirkuk Referendum that do not infringe on the national autonomy of Kurdistan. One such action is to uphold the date of the referendum and the legitimacy of the vote as an inherent right of the Kurdish people in the redress of abuses and crimes against the Kurdish people by the Baathist regime of Saddam Hussein. There is no Iraqi flag that flies over the Kurdish Autonomous Region.

 There is NO cooperation or aid given by the Kurdish peoples to the violence perpetuated by various sects against the people, government and territory of the KRG. There has been a denunciation of such actions. Americans, while opposing US occupation, need to address the issues of acknowledging the political rights of self-government and self-defense by the Kurdish nation. Further, Americans should stand  opposed to any sectarian violence directed at Kurdish nationals and members of various sects. The Kurdish issue should be raised at the United Nations as an issue of indigenous rights, self-determination and preservation of the Kurdish nation against genocidal threats from the nations of Iran and Turkey.

by Martin Zehr (38 articles, 2 quicklinks, 2 diaries, 77 comments) on Wednesday, May 9, 2007 at 11:17:18 PM
 

 

11 comments

 

Tell A Friend

 


Copyright © OpEdNews, 2002-2008

Blog Ads

 

 

 

 

Most Popular Articles
in the Last 2 Days
(by Recommend Emails)

NEW IDEAS ON RESTORING U. S. ECONOMY, for the Next Secretary of Commerce, William Blaine Richardson III by Stephen Fox

End of the Road to Moronity by Rand Clifford

Saving the Big 3 for You and Me ...a message from Michael Moore by Michael Moore

THE LEGACY; Dubya's Musings in the Halls of Never-Never Land by Braun McAsh

Credit Card Crisis Is Here / Derivatives Next by Allen L Roland

Vampires in America by Rob Kall

A Tale of Two Terror Attacks by Dave Lindorff

Obama: Join the Conversation by Richmond Shreve

Paulson shoots another arrow into the heart of the Economy by Andrew Hughes

Leading lives of quiet desperation this holiday season by Sheryl Letzgus McGinnis

Go To Top 50 Most Popular