 |
Add to My Group
9
5
5
View Ratings |
Rate It
Ad Hominem Attacks
By Rady Ananda (about the author) Page 2 of 3 page(s)
San Jose State University characterizes the most frequent ad hominem appeals as attacks on: "The point is that each argument must be evaluated in its own right. Information or suspicions about vested interests, hidden agendas, predilections, or prejudices should, at most, make you more vigilant in your scrutiny of that argument--but they should not be allowed to influence its evaluation. "Only in the case of opinions, expert and otherwise, where you must rely not on the argument or evidence being presented but on the judgment of someone else, may personal or background information be used to evaluate the ideas expressed. "If, for example, a used car vendor tries to prove to you that the car in question is being offered at lower than the average or 'blue book' price, you must ignore the fact that the vendor will profit from the sale, and evaluate the proof. If, on the other hand, that used car vendor says, 'Trust me, this is a good deal,' without further proofs or arguments, you are entitled to take into account the profit motive, the shady reputation of the profession, and anything else you deem to be relevant as a condition of 'trust.'" 9 
OpEdNews is filled with people of great intelligence and creativity. The tough thing for those with a brain (or any talent, really) is to recognize how incredibly hurtful we can be when we show impatience with others who aren't as smart or talented, or who simply don't think the way we do. All of us have different worldviews.
We need to think and write critically. We need to use diplomacy, tact and grace. Keep our judgments about other people's ideas off the table. Stick to the facts and conclusions. Debate the facts and/or conclusions. Keep our emotions out of it.
We're not sitting around in some bar or in our private homes having these discussions. We're writing this stuff in public, on a popular website that gets over 700,000 unique visitors a month. We are diplomats of progressive ideals and Leftist thought. We have to act accordingly.
2 mathew, Logic & Fallacies: Constructing a Logical Argument, Infidels.org, 1997.
3 Richard Nordquist, ad hominem.
4 N.S. Gill, Ad Hominem.
5 T. Edward Damer, Attacking Faulty Reasoning, 4th ed., Wadsworth, 2001, as cited by Richard Nordquist, ibid.
6 Whitman, ibid.
7 mathew, ibid.
8 mathew, ibid.
9 San Jose State University, Mission: Critical.
Also see Ad Hominem Fallacies of Relevance.
In 2004, Rady Ananda joined the growing community of (more...)
The views expressed in this article are the sole responsibility of the author
and do not necessarily reflect those of this website or its editors.
 Contact Author |
Contact Editor |
 View Authors' Articles |
$45.00
Lowest New Price $24.94
Number of pages: 320
Publisher: Oxford University Press, USA
by Alliance of Artists' Communities
$24.95
Lowest New Price $13.47
Number of pages: 336
Publisher: Allworth Press
by Cheryl Charles
$22.95
Lowest New Price $1.49
Number of pages: 250
Publisher: Personhood Press
by Brett Johnson
$19.95
Number of pages: 299
Publisher: Indaba Publishing
| 156 comments |
Want to post your own comment on this Article? 
|
||||
|
||||||||||||||
News (0) 
Touching (0) 
Funny (0) 
Supported (2) 
Interesting (2) 
Inspiring (0) Tell a Friend:
|
Copyright © 2002-2009, OpEdNews |
